The metamorphosis of the old woman into a beautiful young maiden
when she is beaten by the protagonist is a pivotal moment in the final
version of Gogol&soft;'s
Gogol&soft; began work on
Although many critics have commented upon Xoma Brut's fleeting vision of the Alcinoe-like water-nymph during his erotic ride with the old woman, few have included it as a step in the woman's transformation into a beautiful maiden or integrated this moment into a coherent reading of the text. I argue that the description of the water-nymph, which is the lyrical climax of the tale, corresponds to the artist's creative vision at the moment of its conception—the unembodied feminine ideal of Gogol&soft;'s Romantic aesthetics. I show that as the story progresses, she continues to metamorphose: with each of Xoma Brut's subsequent encounters with her she is described in increasingly masculine and material terms until she is finally nothing more than a purely bodily—and grammatically masculine—corpse (trup). This transformation is echoed by a shift in Gogol&soft;'s use of verbs of sight that reinforces Xoma's changing relationship with what begins as his own internal vision and turns into a separate, independent material being, the object of his gaze.
My analysis of these parallel shifts in the text leads to several
layers of metaliterary interpretation. First, I compare Xoma's fear of
the dead maiden to a writer's anxiety over losing the essence of
cherished ideas when they are given fixed form in writing: Xoma's
terror grows as he faces ever more concrete, fixed, and masculine
versions of his former ideal. While it might appear that Gogol&soft;
presents this as a universal and unresolvable dilemma for the artist,
I suggest that he sets up this model only to disprove it. In my
conclusion I contrast the unsuccessful artist
Xoma with
Gogol&soft; himself, hypothesizing that the continual
transmogrification of the female body could represent Gogol&soft;'s
own method of selecting, appropriating, and exploiting existing
folkloric and literary forms as he searched for a new, individual form
of expression.